We adopted Mia, a 6 year old Tabby, 2 months ago. It was stressful for her as her previous owner was no longer able to care for her. She has a very sweet disposition and seemed to settle in. But there is one big problem! Her food and litter box are in a separate room from our other cat, Andy's. When she was first here and was the only one going in her box (Andy now seems to like to use both, but she won't use his) things were fine. Now, even though I clean it out, after every possible use, she will pee in it, but, will defecate on the rug anywhere from beside the box to 3-4 feet away from the box. How do I stop this? I would like to move them both to the same box (it is one of those "self-cleaning" ones, which is so less time consuming! I'm afraid if I take away her box she will start peeing all over the place as well. Help!